Google’s own checklist for hiring an SEO company

The questions Google says to ask, the red flags it lists, and three more for dental practices.

Google has a page for business owners called “Do you need an SEO?” It’s one of the most useful things Google has written, and few owners have read it. Here’s what it says, followed by how I’d answer each question if you asked me.

First: you might not need one

Google says a small local business can do much of its own SEO, starting with Google’s free SEO Starter Guide. It also says the best time to hire help is when you’re redesigning your website or launching a new one, so the site is built right from the start.

The questions Google says to ask

Google’s questionMy answer
Can you show me past work and success stories?Yes. My work page shows real client results.
Do you follow Google Search Essentials?Yes. My recommendations link to Google’s own documentation.
What results should I expect, and when?Your business name usually ranks within weeks. Local SEO work usually shows clear movement in 3 to 6 months.
How do you measure success?Calls, bookings, and visits from Google, plus your own Search Console data.
What’s your experience in my industry and city?Dental, healthcare, and local businesses across Northern Virginia, Maryland, and DC.
How will we communicate?You talk to me directly, and I reply within one business day.
Will you share every change you make, and why?Yes. Every change is in your monthly report, in plain English.

Google also says a good SEO asks about your business: what makes you different, who your competitors are, and how your customers find you. If they don’t, find someone who does.

The red flags Google lists

  • Guaranteed #1 rankings. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
  • A “special relationship” with Google, or a “priority submit” offer.
  • Requiring a link back to the SEO. Google says you should never have to link to your SEO.
  • Link schemes, or “submitting your site to thousands of search engines.”
  • Secrecy. If they won’t explain what they’re changing, walk away.
  • Cold emails saying your site “isn’t listed in the major search engines.”
  • AI search advice that doesn’t match Google’s own guidance. Google now asks owners to check “AEO” and “GEO” claims against its documentation.

About audits and access

If an SEO offers an audit, Google says to give them read-only access to Search Console, not full control. That’s all I ask for during a Marketing Assessment. The free AI visibility check needs no access at all.

Three more I’d ask as a dental practice

Who owns the website and domain? Your domain should be registered in your practice’s name. Ask when the website files become yours, and what happens to them if you leave.

What exactly is included each month? Ask for specifics: how often your Google Business Profile is updated, how reviews are handled, and how many website changes are included.

Will you sign a business associate agreement? If your website collects any patient information, such as appointment requests, the company handling it should sign a BAA. It’s a quick way to tell whether they understand healthcare.

Remember

Google is clear that you’re responsible for what your SEO does to your site. If something sounds too good to be true, ask them to show you where Google says it.

Sources from Google: Do you need an SEO? · Evaluating third-party SEO advice · SEO Starter Guide

I write these guides from my own client work and Google’s official documentation. I use AI tools to research and I check every fact against Google’s guidance before publishing.

By James, founder of Mannoryn Tech · Published November 5, 2026 · Updated November 13, 2026

Replies within one business day

Let’s find out how patients find you.

  • A free walkthrough of your website, Google profile, and AI search presence
  • A written plan with prices you can see up front
  • No pressure to sign anything